Choosing the right guitar is an important step for any musician. It influences not only how comfortable your playing will be but also the learning process itself and your motivation to keep practicing. One of the first questions beginner guitarists face is: should I choose a pure acoustic guitar or an electro-acoustic model?
Both types of instruments have their own unique features, advantages, and limitations. A pure acoustic guitar is the classic choice, ideal for both home playing and live performances. At the same time, an electro-acoustic guitar provides additional possibilities: it can be connected to an amplifier, used for direct recording without microphones, and offers the opportunity to experiment with sound effects.
To make an informed decision, it's essential to consider your playing environment and available budget. In this article, we’ll explore the key differences between acoustic and electro-acoustic guitars, weigh their pros and cons, and help you choose the instrument that best suits your goals.
What is an Acoustic Guitar?
An acoustic guitar is a traditional stringed instrument that produces sound without any electronic amplification. Its tone is generated by the vibrations of the strings, resonating through the guitar’s body, which naturally amplifies these vibrations and creates a rich, authentic sound. Acoustic guitars come in various shapes and sizes, but they share some common characteristics:
- The guitar body acts as a natural amplifier, giving the instrument a warm and expressive tone. Depending on the body size and type of wood, guitars can sound quite different.
- The absence of built-in electronics makes the guitar independent of external amplifiers and gear.
- Acoustic guitars vary widely, including classical guitars, steel-string acoustics (folk and dreadnought models), as well as 12-string guitars.
- The materials used in the guitar’s body significantly affect the sound. For example, cedar produces a soft, rounded tone, whereas spruce offers a brighter, clearer sound.
When considering the choice between acoustic and electro-acoustic guitars, pure acoustics offer several distinct advantages:
- Natural Sound – without additional processing, amplifiers, or equalizers, you get a pure and authentic tone.
- Simple Construction – no electronics make the guitar reliable and less demanding in terms of maintenance.
- Affordability – in most cases, a pure acoustic guitar is less expensive than a comparable electro-acoustic model.
- Portability – you can play anywhere without worrying about connections or additional equipment.
An acoustic guitar is a great choice if you’re just starting your learning journey and want to focus on developing your technique. It delivers a natural sound particularly suited to genres like folk, classical, country, and acoustic rock. This instrument will be the best option if you don’t plan to perform on stage or use amplification.
What is an Electro-Acoustic Guitar?
An electro-acoustic guitar is a hybrid instrument combining traditional acoustic sound with the ability to connect to an amplifier. Externally, it looks nearly identical to a standard acoustic guitar but is equipped with built-in pickups and a preamplifier, allowing you to amplify the sound through speakers or record it directly without using microphones. Its construction typically includes:
- A piezo pickup, which converts string vibrations into an electrical signal.
- A preamplifier, boosting the signal to produce high-quality sound when amplified.
- An equalizer, enabling you to adjust the guitar's tone directly on the instrument.
- An output jack (usually a 6.3 mm jack), allowing the guitar to connect to external equipment.
When comparing an electro-acoustic guitar with a purely acoustic guitar, electro-acoustics have several distinct advantages:
- Amplification Capability – makes the instrument ideal for live performances.
- Direct Sound Recording – allows you to connect the guitar to a computer or audio interface and get a clean signal without ambient noise.
- Tone Adjustment – the built-in equalizer enables you to shape the guitar’s tone to suit various musical styles.
- Versatile Usage – you can perform acoustically or through an amplifier, adapting your sound to different situations.
An electro-acoustic guitar is suitable if you plan to perform on stage, play in a band, record guitar without external microphones, or experiment with different sounds and effects. However, for beginners, it might be slightly more challenging, as it requires not only playing skills but also an understanding of electronics.
Photo by Chris Hardy on Unsplash
Price and Quality: What Should You Consider?
When choosing between a pure acoustic and an electro-acoustic guitar, it’s essential to consider both the pricing and quality of the instrument. Prices can vary significantly depending on materials, brand, and electronics. Therefore, it’s crucial to understand exactly what you're paying for before making a purchase.
1. How Does the Guitar Type Affect Price?
The primary factor influencing price differences between an acoustic and an electro-acoustic guitar is the presence of electronics. Pure acoustic guitars typically cost less, as they don't require built-in components such as piezo pickups, preamplifiers, or equalizers. This allows manufacturers to focus more on the quality of the wood and craftsmanship, crucial factors that determine the guitar's acoustic sound.
Electro-acoustic guitars are generally more expensive due to their additional built-in components. These elements complicate production, require extra investments in materials, and demand careful assembly — ultimately reflected in a higher price. As a result, electro-acoustic models offer greater versatility and convenience for various playing situations, though you’ll need to pay more for this flexibility.
However, it's important to note that a higher price doesn't always mean better acoustic quality. For the same amount, you might find an acoustic guitar made from higher-quality tonewoods compared to an electro-acoustic model in the same price category. This aspect is especially relevant if your priority is pure acoustic sound quality, without the need for amplification.
2. What to Look for When Purchasing a Guitar?
To avoid overpaying and ensure you're buying a high-quality instrument, pay close attention to the materials, build quality, and — in the case of electro-acoustic models — the quality of the built-in electronics.
The type of wood used in a guitar greatly affects its sound. Budget guitars usually feature laminated wood, which provides durability but lacks the rich, deep tone offered by solid wood. Solid-wood guitars deliver a more natural and resonant tone but typically come at a higher price. If your budget is limited, consider a guitar with a solid wood top and laminated back and sides. This configuration is an optimal compromise between price and quality.
Pay attention to the guitar’s craftsmanship. The body should be free of gaps and cracks, and the neck should be straight without noticeable bends or warps. Strings shouldn't be positioned too high above the frets, as this can cause discomfort, particularly for beginner players.
If you’re looking at an electro-acoustic model, make sure to thoroughly test the built-in electronics. The equalizer and preamplifier should operate without noise or crackling, and the amplified sound should be clear and balanced. Cheap electronics can negatively impact the overall sound, so if your budget is tight, it might be better to choose a high-quality acoustic guitar rather than overspending on an electro-acoustic model with subpar electronics.
3. Should You Buy a Guitar with Future Needs in Mind?
If you’re a beginner, you might wonder whether it makes sense to invest immediately in an electro-acoustic guitar if you don't plan on performing on stage anytime soon. The answer depends on your goals and budget.
If your budget allows, an electro-acoustic guitar can be an excellent long-term investment, especially if you eventually plan to perform live or record your music. However, if your priority is obtaining the highest possible acoustic quality within your available budget, it might be wiser to opt for a pure acoustic guitar. At the initial stages of learning, built-in electronics aren't essential, allowing you to fully focus on developing your playing technique without distractions.
Moreover, if in the future you find yourself needing amplification, you don't necessarily have to buy a new guitar. Pure acoustic guitars can easily be upgraded by installing aftermarket electronics, granting you electro-acoustic functionality without significant additional expenses.
Tips for Upgrading Your Acoustic Guitar to Electro-Acoustic
If you’ve initially chosen a pure acoustic guitar, but later find yourself needing amplification or recording capabilities, you can easily equip it with a pickup system. This upgrade allows you to connect your guitar to an amplifier or audio interface while preserving its natural acoustic tone. There are several pickup types available, and your choice depends on your desired sound and ease of use:
- Piezo pickups are installed under the bridge saddle, offering a clear, noise-free sound. However, they can sometimes sound dry and typically require an equalizer for tone shaping.
- Magnetic pickups are mounted in the guitar’s soundhole, providing a warmer, fuller tone, although they might appear somewhat bulky.
- Microphone-based systems deliver a highly natural acoustic sound but can be prone to background noise and feedback.
- Combination systems blend piezo pickups and microphones, balancing clean signal quality with a natural acoustic tone.
The main advantage of such an upgrade is cost-effectiveness. Installing a pickup system is generally less expensive than purchasing a new guitar. Additionally, you can select a system tailored to your personal playing style. Choosing a removable pickup also ensures your instrument remains unmodified, preserving its original condition.
However, there are some drawbacks to consider. Factory-installed electronics in electro-acoustic guitars are typically better balanced, whereas aftermarket installations might yield varying sound quality. Moreover, not all acoustic guitars are suitable for upgrading — some instruments have thinner or uniquely shaped bodies that make installing pickups challenging.
Before proceeding with an installation, decide on the type of pickup you prefer. If you wish to keep your guitar unaltered, consider removable pickups that require no drilling. Built-in systems, such as piezo or combined pickups, involve more complex installation and are best handled by professional technicians.
Some pickup systems require a preamplifier to boost the output signal, so consider in advance whether you need models equipped with an equalizer and volume controls. For maximum flexibility, choose systems offering the ability to switch between different signal sources.
Upgrading your acoustic guitar is an excellent way to expand its capabilities without investing in an entirely new instrument. The key is to select the right pickup system to achieve the most natural and comfortable sound possible.
Conclusion
The choice between an electro-acoustic and a pure acoustic guitar depends entirely on your goals, budget, personal preferences, and playing style. Both instruments have their unique advantages, and selecting the right option will make your guitar-playing experience more enjoyable, comfortable, and inspiring.
If you’re a beginner guitarist and plan on playing at home, for personal enjoyment, or in small gatherings, a pure acoustic guitar will be an excellent choice. It requires no additional equipment, offers a natural sound, and helps you focus purely on developing your playing technique. On the other hand, if you want to perform live, record music, or experiment with your sound, an electro-acoustic guitar provides greater versatility. Thanks to its built-in piezo pickup and preamplifier, you can connect it to an amplifier, use effects, and easily record in a studio setting.
However, it isn’t necessary to immediately purchase an electro-acoustic guitar. If you find you need amplification later, you can always upgrade a standard acoustic guitar by installing a pickup, effectively transforming it into an electro-acoustic instrument. This will allow you to use amplifiers and audio interfaces while preserving the natural tone of your guitar. Such an option suits those who don’t currently require electronics but wish to keep their options open for future enhancement.
No matter which guitar you choose, it’s important to properly care for it, ensuring it maintains its sound and appearance for years to come. To learn the essential rules of guitar maintenance, be sure to read our article: “How to Properly Care for Your Guitar to Maintain Its Sound”.
Afterward, your next step is mastering your playing technique. One of the most expressive and beautiful styles is fingerstyle guitar, which allows you to play melody, accompaniment, and rhythm simultaneously. If you’re interested in learning this technique, check out our comprehensive guide: “What is Fingerstyle Guitar? A Complete Guide for Beginners”.
Above all, play with joy, enjoy the process, and never stop improving!
